I am the person who will destroy China. (madman101) wrote,
I am the person who will destroy China.
madman101

"PRIVACY IS THEFT"

Think the giants of Silicon Valley have your best interests at heart? Think again



In one of the sharpest critiques of machine learning that I’ve come across, Harvard computer scientist James Mickens attributes many of the current disasters of the tech industry to what he calls the doctrine of “technological manifest destiny”.

The core tenets of this quasi-religious belief system are:

1. Technology is value-neutral and therefore will automatically lead to good outcomes for everyone.

2. Thus, new kinds of technology should be deployed as quickly as possible, even if we lack a general idea of how the technology works or what the societal impact will be.

3. History is generally uninteresting because the past has nothing to teach us...

The polite term for the delusions that grip the lords of Silicon Valley (and their fans elsewhere) is technological determinism: the belief that technology is what really drives history and that they are on the right side of that history. It may also explain why they have manifested such blithe indifference to the malign effects that their machines are having on society. After all, if technology is the remorseless bulldozer that flattens everything in its path, then why waste time and energy fretting about it or imagining that it might be controlled?

Determinism, in that sense, removes human agency from the picture. The role assigned to people is essentially that of passive or active consumers of whatever wonders the tech industry chooses to lay before them. It also removes politics from the frame, because politics is about how societies make collective choices and determinism holds that there are no choices to be made. One of the infuriating tragedies of our time is how so many of our ruling elites seem to have swallowed this snake oil and how long it has then taken them to wake up to what’s going on.

Read more at the GUARDIAN.
Subscribe

  • Big Bands, Rolling Through My Soul!

    I have started up my music list by genre again, meaning that all the old big band music has been playing first, by year. When I was a kid, I was…

  • Real Life Journal

    Here's a list of the LJ people I met in real life. The daughter of the City Assessor, or something like that. She was raving about,…

  • The Ununderstood

    I had a few dreams. One had George Harrison in it.. He had been adopted by an American family. So I guess he had come back to life. And there was…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 0 comments